SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, and Bankroll (8/31/23)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $1,062.25

My plan was to get back to doing extensive full-card analysis for the Thursday program. Between an insane week at work to this point and the slog that’s been the 2023 Saratoga meet, that didn’t happen. It might come back this weekend, though that sounded way more enticing before the underwhelming Saturday overnight came out.

One note before we move on: If you haven’t read Wednesday’s edition of The Saratoga Special, you should. Joe and Sean Clancy both have phenomenal columns on this summer’s cursed meet and the state of horse racing in general.

They won’t want to hear this, I’m sure, but without the Clancy’s taking a chance on me as an intern for part of the 2011 Saratoga season, I’m probably not where I am today. They’re awesome people and fantastic writers who hit their assignments out of the park this past week.

WEDNESDAY’S RESULTS: I tried to bet the jump race, which, of course, got cancelled.

THURSDAY’S PLAY: I’ll focus on the fifth, which boasts a massive 14-horse field. I’ll start with $3 exactas that use #8 NICKEL NICKEL and #14 SCREAMING UNCLE on top of those two, #1 BARGAINING POWER, and #10 DISAPPEARANCE. I’ll also box my top two picks for $2 more. Finally, I’ll have an $8 win ticket on Nickel Nickel, whose 15-1 morning line price hits me as an overlay.

TOTAL WAGERED: $30.

ANALYSIS/SELECTIONS

Wednesday: 5-for-8
Meet: 77-for-248

Best Bet: Life Talk, Race 2
Longshot: Nickel Nickel, Race 5

R1

Deep Conviction
Madaket entry
Sassy Princess

R2

Life Talk
Paradise Lane
Classy Mischief

R3

Fancy Joke (MTO)
Howdumakeurmoney
Masterof the Tunes

R4

Ramsey entry
Falcone entry
Sweet Heidelberg

R5

Screaming Uncle
Nickel Nickel
Bargaining Power

R6

Tivy (MTO)
Charging
Brennan’s War

R7

Gala Brand
Nomos
Spirit Prince

R8

G Munning
Bank Frenzy
Cicciobello

R9

Giroovin
Inevtabl Conection
Ice Road

R10

Wishing On a Star (MTO)
Lady Hamilton
Miss M M

SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, and Bankroll (8/30/23)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $1,062.25

A few items before we get started. First, more detailed analysis is coming back for Thursday (I simply didn’t have a lot of time early this week).

Secondly, if you haven’t read Ryan Metzger’s Paulick Report letter to the editor, you should. It’s powerful, and as I told him, I wouldn’t change a single solitary word of it. The time for inaction in horse racing should be over, and that needs to be shouted from the rooftops even if grumpy people in my Twitter mentions don’t want to hear about it.

Finally, I’d be remiss to not mention the passing of Jonathan Sheppard. You’ll hear a bunch of stories about him this week, I’m sure, and all of them will be amazing. Here’s a tip, though: The best one involves Richard Migliore and is best told by him. Find him and ask about it. You won’t regret it.

SUNDAY’S RESULTS: The favorite I tried to beat won the fifth. After scratches, I dropped $14.

WEDNESDAY’S PLAY: I haven’t done this all summer and I don’t have a ton of strong opinions elsewhere on the card, so let’s bet the jump race. I don’t love the heavily-favored entry and actually prefer the second choice, #5 BARBADOS. I’ll have a $30 win bet on that one.

TOTAL WAGERED: $30.

ANALYSIS/SELECTIONS

Sunday: 2-for-11
Meet: 72-for-240

Best Bet: Cupid’s Heart, Race 4
Longshot: Dontbelate, Race 6

R1

Barbados
Go Poke the Bear
Hudson River entry

R2

Stonestreet entry
Bento
Waskesiu

R3

Call Her Bluff (MTO)
Entrepreneurship
Leslie’s Loot

R4

Cupid’s Heart
Huntress for Hire
Adeliese’s Smile

R5

Gilmore (MTO)
Ramblin’ Wreck
Let’s Go Big Blue

R6

Printrack
Dontbelate
No More Talk

R7

Paris Style (MTO)
She’s Mo Bubbly
Absolute Control

R8

Olga Isabel
Leave No Trace
Movie Moxy

R9

Miz Sense (MTO)
Gala Brand
Brocknardini

R10

I’m Just (MTO)
Prix de West
Impazible Prince

INTERLUDE: A Disappointing, Tragic 2023 Saratoga Meet

When things get weird, writers write, and I can think of no weirder time during my career than this summer.

I’m writing the bulk of this column Saturday night, hours after Travers Day. It should’ve been a celebration of the best Saratoga has to offer. Arcangelo stamped himself as the best 3-year-old in the country with a win in the Midsummer Derby, and stalwarts Echo Zulu and Gunite both won major stakes races.

Of course, all of that pales in comparison to what happened on the rest of the card. Two more horses passed away due to catastrophic injuries. One of them, New York Thunder, seemed on his way to victory in the Allen Jerkens when he went down in midstretch, to the horror of the Saratoga crowd and those watching around the country on FOX. It’s the second time in a month a major breakdown has happened in a race broadcast on that network (Maple Leaf Mel, of course, suffered a fatal injury in the Test).

Now, everyone involved is looking for a path forward. Many on horse racing Twitter, a highly-opinionated space even in the best of times, called for the rest of the meet to be cancelled. Whether or not that’s deemed the most sound decision is anyone’s guess, but the constant barrage of rain this summer at Saratoga sure seems to have changed the track, not unlike what happened at Santa Anita a few years ago. Rain in upstate New York is nothing new, but we haven’t seen a summer like this in a very, very long time.

An emergency meeting was called Saturday night. I imagine we’ll know more in the coming days. For now, though, all I can say is that I’m sick to my stomach. I was excited for the start of this season, as I have been most summers during my life.

Then it started.

There’s no aspect of this meet that hasn’t been disappointing in some form or fashion. The weather has wreaked havoc on programs, turning competitive turf races into five or six-horse affairs out of the Wilson chute (which has gotten WAY too much use). Inquiries and objections have been handled, to be kind, in a very inconsistent manner by stewards, and a few decisions have rendered members of the New York Racing Association’s own TV crew speechless. Breakdowns haven’t just happened. They’ve happened too frequently, on big stages, in full view of not just hardened horseplayers, but families crammed into spots on the track aprons that are usually empty at other NYRA locales.

There have also been plenty of headaches induced on the wagering end. Computer groups, while shut out of NYRA’s win pools, have started hammering exacta payoffs down to where those combinations routinely pay significantly less than they should. The biggest races on the calendar have struggled to draw full fields. In addition, of course, there was the fiasco where surfaces were changed with one minute to post before the first leg of a Pick Five.

(Quick note: I got some heat for my response to that last chain of events, which probably wasn’t worded the best in the heat of the moment but did say that I needed to know more about communication behind the scenes before crushing NYRA. As it turned out, the organization lobbied for a delay that would’ve given players a chance to change tickets, and those efforts were rebuffed. It was a bad situation all around, communication from NYRA to horseplayers was far from ideal, and that shouldn’t ever repeat itself, but it turns out I may have been…at least partially right?)

The simple thing to do is blame one organization or group of people. It’s easy to blame NYRA, or horsepeople who are perceived to operate in certain ways. Unfortunately, while a few individual arguments aren’t without decent points, the bigger answer is almost certainly far more complex and doesn’t lend itself to the lazy ways we tend to communicate with one another.

We don’t breed as many horses as we used to. The ones we produce don’t run as much, or for as long a time period. Some are bred with 2-year-old sales in mind, not 4-year-old races, which leads to longterm soundness issues and, in my opinion, a weaker breed in general. Owners consolidate their stock with fewer trainers, leading to field size headaches, and some of those trainers have rap sheets longer than Jack Kerouac’s scroll of “On the Road.” Computer-assisted groups are problematic to the average bettor, and horse racing as a whole has no idea what to do with them, or how to effectively answer the question, “what is a foul that merits disqualification?” Finally, of course, Mother Nature has been Saratoga’s worst enemy, and there have been times NYRA has been caught flat-footed in its response to the elements. Mix all of that together, and you get…this.

There aren’t many people in horse racing’s community who are more connected with one track than I am with Saratoga. It’s where I grew up, where I made my bones as a writer and handicapper, and where I’m happy to help as many people as I can in whatever way(s) I can. Even folks who think I’m a moron and who enjoy bashing me for existing are welcome to come find me and break bread at a racetrack whenever I’m at one (it’s not like I’m a hard guy to find).

I’ve had people tell me I’m being too hard on horse racing. I’ve also seen people say I’m lobbying for a job with NYRA. Neither of those viewpoints are true, and to be honest, if people are saying both things, I’m probably being pretty fair.

My experience and perspective means that I see these 40 days in upstate New York as a representation of the best horse racing has to offer, in front of the best fans in the sport. Instead (and please excuse the too-easy cliche coming up), a perfect storm of horrible things have converged on the small city in upstate New York. Instead of being reminded how great this game can be at its best, this meet has shown us how hard it can be at its worst, and it’s done so with staggering, torturous regularity.

In short, what I want is both simple and grand: I want Saratoga to feel like Saratoga again.

I don’t know if that can be done this coming week. To be honest, after the meet that’s taken place this summer, I’m not entirely sure it can happen when Saratoga opens its doors in 2024. I love this place very, very much, but there are no two ways about it: If Saratoga continues feeling less like the Saratoga we know and love and more like the setting of a different “Black Mirror” episode every day, a lot of things are in big, big trouble.

SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, and Bankroll (8/27/23)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $1,076.25

I’m going to be honest, folks: My heart’s not in this one. I’ve got picks below for anyone who wants them, but my traditional analysis isn’t happening, and I’m pretty relieved to have plans during most of tomorrow’s card (if you’re curious, I’m touring a possible wedding venue with my long-suffering fiancee, and then we’re seeing “Oppenheimer”).

I handicapped the card Saturday morning, before the events of Travers Day unfolded before a massive audience. One horse, Nobel, suffered a fatal injury on a gallop-out. Another, New York Thunder, catastrophically broke down while appearing to have the Grade 1 Allen Jerkens won by as much as he wanted.

Those in racing, from fans and bettors to owners and trainers, shouldn’t have to wonder whether or not horses come back safe and sound after races. However, that’s been a common occurrence during what’s easily the weirdest Saratoga meet of my lifetime. I’m no expert on equine health, but the constant barrage of rain all summer long sure seems to have affected both the main track and the turf courses to an alarming degree.

I don’t know what the solution is. Maybe there isn’t one. If that’s the case and it doesn’t scare you, check your pulse.

SATURDAY’S RESULTS: Dynadrive didn’t kick on, and Shop Lifting suffered a heartbreaking loss. I dropped $45, but it surely doesn’t seem all that important in the grand scheme of things.

SUNDAY’S PLAY: If I’ve ever been less enthusiastic about a Saratoga card, I don’t know when. For the sake of this section, I’ll go to the sixth, where I think #7 ROCKET AND ROLL is a vulnerable favorite. I’ll play a $3 exacta box using #5 FLYING IN STYLE, #6 COACH PITINO, and #8 PURE FIRE, and I’ll use those three to finish $4 doubles that start in the fifth (the Yaddo) with #8 WHATLOVELOOKSLIKE.

TOTAL WAGERED: $30.

ANALYSIS/SELECTIONS

Saturday: 5-for-13
Meet: 70-for-229

Best Bet: Whatlovelookslike, Race 5
Longshot: American Grant, Race 8

R1

Soloshot (MTO)
Marco T.
Needed

R2

Timely Conquest
Ichiban
Cairo Sugar

R3

Un Ojo (MTO)
Spirit of St Louis
Dakota Gold

R4

The Wine Steward
Trust Fund
Whatchatalkinabout

R5

Whatlovelookslike
Runaway Rumour
Spungie

R6

Pure Fire
Flying in Style
Coach Pitino

R7

Concerti
Stellamaris
My Shea D Lady

R8

Gem Mint Ten
One Headlight
American Grant

R9

Sandy’s Garden (MTO)
Weekend Rags
Linarite

R10

Maker’s Candy
Allure of Money
Drake’s Passage

R11

Boston Strong Mama
Autumn
Splashy

SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, and Bankroll (8/26/23; TRAVERS DAY)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $1,121.25

FRIDAY’S RESULTS: Neither Fierceness nor Ontheonesandtwos ever looked like losers, though double payoffs suffered a bit due to three scratches in the latter race. Still, it was a pretty good day, as $40 in bets returned $202.

SATURDAY’S PLAY: I’ll focus on the fifth and sixth, and I really, REALLY hope the fifth stays on the turf. I’ll have $20 win bets on #1 DYNADRIVE (race 5) and #4 SHOP LIFTING (race 6), and I’ll link them with a $5 cold double.

TOTAL WAGERED: $45.

ANALYSIS/SELECTIONS

Friday: 3-for-10
Meet: 65-for-216

Best Bet: Shop Lifting, Race 6
Longshot: Verstappen, Race 11

R1

Catire Vizcaya
Walstib
Secret Lover

#2 CATIRE VIZCAYA (3-1): Dueled through legitimate fractions in his debut before settling for second, and that day’s third-place finisher came right back to win. Irad Ortiz, Jr., sees fit to ride, and this one should be prominent from the jump; #8 WALSTIB (2-1): Ran well when second in his unveiling for a barn whose first-time starters aren’t usually fully cranked. Based on that, he’s a logical favorite, but I’d love to know why this barn also entered #1 STUNNEM; #3 SECRET LOVER (5-1): Had every reason to not run a jump in his debut after a terrible start, but while he was a distant fourth, he showed plenty of late interest. This barn has done well with its small string here this summer, and this is another that could step forward in the Travers Day lid-lifter.

R2

Golden Arm (MTO)
Barber entry
Ortus

BARBER ENTRY (9/5): I prefer #1 CITY MISCHIEF, who ran very well in defeat last time out in what doubled as his first effort since December. It’s true that he hasn’t won in a while, but many of his prior outings were against open company, not NY-breds; #2 ORTUS (3-1): Was second behind a much-the-best winner over yielding going last time out at Belmont. The inside draw can be tricky for closers, but we’ve also seen him show some tactical speed in the past, too; #9 ATHENRY (15-1): Ran too poorly to be true last time out downstate and has been working steadily at the Spa. His two-back effort was actually pretty solid, and a repeat of that effort could get him a check at a big price.

R3

Mistical Curlin 
Money Supply
St. Elmo

#4 MISTICAL CURLIN (2-1): Is at his best over an off track, which we’re likely to see at least early in the Saturday card, and the stretchout to two turns shouldn’t be a problem. His early speed should be an asset in a race without much of it elsewhere; #3 MONEY SUPPLY (9/5): Capitalized on a big class drop earlier in the meet and won going away over weaker competition in a restricted claiming event. He goes to a new barn here, which is always a question mark, but he’s got back speed figures that would certainly make him a major player; #2 ST. ELMO (8-1): Had a perfect trip in Indiana last time out, where he broke his maiden after being part of a very slow early pace. He probably has to step forward, but it’s also possible he’s embracing going two turns after three sprints to start his career.

R4

Scocciatore
Lord Captain
My Harbors Dream

#1 SCOCCIATORE (9/2): Stalked and pounced to win a similar race here earlier in the summer and is a candidate to do the same here. He clearly loves Saratoga and seems to be doing well for a barn that’s enjoyed a very solid meet; #6 LORD CAPTAIN (7/2): Very clearly didn’t enjoy the stretchout last time out and cuts back to one turn for this event. He was a good second two back going seven furlongs, and his lone start over a wet track was a win; #2 MY HARBORS DREAM (12-1): Has won two of three starts since being claimed by David Jacobson in April, and one of them was a solid last-out score at Delaware Park. This well-traveled gelding (a Washington-bred) has enough speed to sit close and be among an onslaught of pursuers as the field turns for home.

R5

Tonal Impact (MTO)
Flying P entry
Nobel

#1 DYNADRIVE (5-1): Gets a much-needed class drop after chasing graded stakes foes for quite a while. He loves this turf course, he won the Lure last year, and I think he’s got a big chance assuming this event stays on the lawn; #6 NOBEL (7/2): Comes over from Europe, where he most recently ran a close-up fourth in an 18-horse event at York. He’s proven at this distance, and trainer Brendan Walsh does good work with horses making their first starts in North America; #2 CATCH THAT PARTY (4-1): Has hit the board in five of his six local turf starts, and his recent off-the-turf race is an obvious throwout. The win two back at Belmont was sharp, Irad returns to the saddle, and his usual race gives him a chance in a race where I think likely favorite #7 JAMES ALOYSIUS is vulnerable.

R6

Shop Lifting
Cowgirl Charm
Colonial Rose

#4 SHOP LIFTING (6-1): Has been working very well for a trainer who sometimes doesn’t ask his first-time starters for a whole lot. This daughter of Into Mischief sold for $475,000 as a yearling, is out of a Grade 1-winning mare (one kin to top sprinter Trappe Shot), and this price hits me as a significant overlay; #6 COWGIRL CHARM (5-1): Sold for $160,000 at Keeneland despite a modest-at-first-glance pedigree, but there’s a lot of class on the dam’s side. This one is kin to five horses that have hit the track. They’re all winners, and the dam herself is a half-sister to Grade 1 winner Cupid, among others; #2 COLONIAL ROSE (7/2): Has an experience edge over most of this group, having run second in her debut last month. She has every right to improve, but I’m not sure how strong that field she faced last time really was, and there are some intriguing prospects in this one.

R7

Elite Power
Gunite
Pipeline

#3 ELITE POWER (1/2): Has won eight in a row, including several Grade 1 events, and looms large in the Grade 1 Forego. His win in the Vanderbilt was excellent, we know he can handle seven furlongs, and his usual effort beats these; #2 GUNITE (6/5): Threw everything but the kitchen sink at my top pick last time out but came up a head short. He’s an honest horse who’s only been worse than third twice in 18 lifetime starts, and he figures to be prominent early on; #4 PIPELINE (12-1): Fell victim to one of the deadest rails in Saratoga history last time out, when he went from “loaded” to “empty” very, very quickly. I’m banking on an improved performance second off the bench, and he could spice up the exotics at a price.

R8

Daufuskie Island (MTO)
Souper Quest
Southern Horse

#13 SOUPER QUEST (3-1): Needs a scratch to draw in but looms large if he does. He romped in his debut and, in his most recent start, ran second to a Saratoga-loving turf sprinter who has since come back to win again; #12 SOUTHERN HORSE (7/2): Comes east after being purchased by David Jacobson earlier this year and has run some very strong races going short over the Santa Anita turf course. He’s been working steadily here, and he seems like a major player if he’s ready to go; #7 ACOUSTIC AVE (8-1): Is an obvious contender if the race gets moved to dirt, but there’s enough turf pedigree here to make him worth a play at a price. Damsire Street Boss is an excellent turf influence, and he gets Lasix for the first time in his first non-stakes race since a maiden-breaking score here last July.

R9

Arabian Lion
Fort Bragg
New York Thunder

#6 ARABIAN LION (2-1): Has blossomed into a top-tier 3-year-old, albeit a bit later than many expected, and he looms large from a cushy outside post in the Grade 1 Allen Jerkens. His last two races were excellent, and he’s been working up a storm in California ahead of this event; #4 FORT BRAGG (5/2): Cuts back after winning the Grade 3 Dwyer, and that day’s runner-up did everything but win the Grade 2 Jim Dandy next time out. I’m not sure seven furlongs is his preferred trip, but talent-wise, he most definitely fits; #5 NEW YORK THUNDER (5/2): Ran a hole in the wind in annexing the Grade 2 Amsterdam, where he earned a 110 Beyer Speed Figure. He’s 4-for-4 and has every right to be a freak, but repeating that race is a tall order, and that’s what he may have to do.

R10

Echo Zulu
Goodnight Olive
Wicked Halo

#6 ECHO ZULU (7/5): Loves Saratoga and ran a career-best race in dominating the Grade 2 Honorable Miss. The Grade 1 Ballerina is a taller task, but it’s not like she beat weaklings last time out, and I think she’ll be extremely tough to beat here; #7 GOODNIGHT OLIVE (9/5): Is likely a horror-trip third in the Grade 1 Derby City Distaff away from a nine-race win streak, and she got back on the beam last time out at Belmont. Seven furlongs is definitely her preferred distance, the draw is a plus, and she was impressive in winning this race a year ago; #5 WICKED HALO (8-1): Has butted heads with a bunch of these in the past and was a neck back of my second choice two starts ago. She’s 2-for-2 over the Saratoga track, won the Grade 2 Prioress a season ago, and could sit an ideal stalking trip at a price.

R11

Verstappen
Pioneering Spirit
Stone Age

#2 VERSTAPPEN (8-1): Ran second in the Grade 2 Bowling Green, where the frontrunner got an ideal trip and never stopped. I think the pace will be a bit faster here, and that this gelding will love a return to a distance where he won the Grade 2 Elkhorn earlier this year; #5 PIONEERING SPIRIT (8-1): Has won four in a row and scratched out of the John’s Call to run here, which seems like a vote of confidence from a high-percentage barn. Perhaps he needs to improve, but few are better at moving horses forward on this circuit than Linda Rice; #7 STONE AGE (6/5): Ran second in last year’s Grade 1 Breeders’ Cup Turf and makes his first start for Chad Brown. He’s a logical favorite, and I wouldn’t hate him at odds of 5/2 or so. Having said that, he hasn’t won in more than a year and has had several logical chances to break through. Maybe he makes me look like an idiot, but I simply can’t back him at his likely price.

R12

Forte
National Treasure
Mage

#1 FORTE (7/5): Won a controversial renewal of the Jim Dandy to prep for the Grade 1 Travers, and I think he looms large despite going against the winners of all three Triple Crown races. This is his third start off a break that included a scratch from the Kentucky Derby, where he would’ve been the favorite, and I think he stamps himself as the best 3-year-old male with a win in the Midsummer Derby; #5 NATIONAL TREASURE (8-1): Went wire-to-wire to win the Grade 1 Preakness two back before tiring in the Belmont. I don’t see much other early speed in this race, and if the track is once again playing kindly to horses on the front end, he could lead them a long way; #4 MAGE (4-1): Won the Kentucky Derby, was third in the Preakness, and ran a good second in the Grade 1 Haskell. He’s a consistent sort that will do his best running late, and we already know this 10-furlong distance fits him like a glove.

R13

Coalville (MTO)
Brown entry
Conversing

BROWN ENTRY (7/5): The odds hit me as a bit of an underlay, but both #1 RIGHT TO WIN and #1A GROWTH CAPITAL hit me as contenders in here, and you’re getting both for the price of one. The latter, in particular, ran a really good race at Kentucky Downs last fall and may be the one they have to run down; #3 CONVERSING (6-1): Hasn’t been seen since October, but ran well twice last summer and goes out for a barn that does very well with horses coming back off of long layoffs. First-time Lasix is a big plus, as is the continued presence of John Velazquez; #8 TORIGO (6-1): Ran okay to be second in his comeback race in July downstate and could move forward second off the layoff. His connections thought enough of him to try the Grade 2 Pilgrim last fall, and it’s possible he’s got room to move forward in what’s just his fourth career outing.