Andrew’s Play of the Day: 1/3/20

RECORD: 2-0

I played horses at Santa Anita on New Year’s Day and had about the worst handicapping day of my life. It prompted someone on Twitter (a follower, no less) to message me and demand that I give up handicapping publicly, past accomplishments be damned. I responded in kind, saying that I’m going to be the same person until either horse racing goes away or I do.

The response that I got to that was mind-blowing. If you took the time to say something, know that I appreciate you. Part of being in my position is knowing there are going to be days where the only things I pick correctly are clothes that match. On the other hand, another part is having the confidence to trust the process and keep firing, which is what I plan to do.

To the person who tried to tell me to stand down: You’re not the first, you won’t be the last, and I’m not going to be intimidated by anyone like you. If anyone out there agrees with him…well, then go make your own website, with your own picks, and see how easy it is.

THURSDAY’S RESULT: Boston College simply did not show up to the Birmingham Bowl, and Cincinnati rolled to an easy cover en route to the team’s 11th win of the season.

FRIDAY’S PLAY: We’ll shift gears over to college hoops and head to the Colonial Athletic Association. 11-4 Delaware (a team you may want to get familiar with come tournament time) heads to Drexel, where the visiting Blue Hens will be just a one-point favorite. At that spread, give me Delaware, a team that is very capable of scoring lots of points very quickly.

Andrew’s Play of the Day: 1/2/20

RECORD: 1-0

For the first time since I joined it in 2013, I won my fantasy football league. With the trophy came a pretty nice chunk of change, and I wound up buying a new piece of furniture for my living room. Christened as “the couch Saquon Barkley built,” it should be arriving at my Northern California residence next weekend.

That I’m truly excited about all of this scares the bejesus out of me. Nobody ever warns you about the true perils of getting old. It’s not the physical infirmities or the mind tending to wander just a bit more. It’s feeling giddy over buying things in such a way that the 21-year-old version of yourself would scream bloody murder if he/she suddenly materialized.

WEDNESDAY’S RESULT: As a Michigan fan, it sickened me to bet against the Wolverines in the Citrus Bowl. However, Alabama proved to be too much and the Crimson Tide easily covered as 8.5-point favorites, which means I got off to a good start.

THURSDAY’S PLAY: I’ll stick with college football and focus on the Birmingham Bowl. Cincinnati’s only problem this year was an inability to beat Memphis, a good team that put up a fight against Penn State earlier this bowl season. Meanwhile, Boston College fired its coach after a 6-6 season, one where the Eagles went 3-5 in the team’s last eight games. I think Cincinnati wins comfortably, and I’ll take the Bearcats giving 7.5 points.

50 Wishes for Horse Racing in 2020

The last time I wrote something, the finished product became the most-read piece on AndrewChampagne.com. It was a 50-point plan designed to improve horse racing, and while several of the ideas had been ruminating in my brain for years, the drive to write it came from…well, from showing someone that if you accuse me of not having ideas or a drive to get things done, I’m going to take you to school.

I wrote that article in an hour, and honestly, it’s a miracle my keyboard didn’t melt from how fast my fingers moved. When I saw the responses, I was floored. For as much bluster as I appear to have on social media sometimes, I’m quite a different person once the “wannabe pro wrestling manager” shtick goes away. Seeing so many people identify with certain points I made (even when they didn’t agree with everything I wrote) was genuinely powerful, and, to be blunt, it reminded me that I can still write. To everyone who gave that a read and identified with some of it, thank you.

With the end of 2019 upon us, I see fit to offer up wishes for horse racing in the year 2020 and beyond. Since it worked so well last time, I’ll stick to a 50-item list. Some of these may sound a bit familiar if you read my previous piece, but this is meant as more of an idealistic/humorous piece rather than a memo outlining policy initiatives to be undertaken by the holder of a job I’ll never get.

Got ideas of your own, or thoughts on my list? Tweet me or shoot me an email via this site’s “contact” function. As I will make clear every time I do this, I see everything that comes through, and I respond to most of it.

With that in mind, here we go with a list of 50 wishes for the new year!

1) Friends of mine/all-around good guys Joe Nevills and Ernie Munick get carte blanche to go as long as they want in acceptance speeches at the Eclipse Awards later this month.

2) The place for true storytelling within the sport widens. The best pieces in racing aren’t bought and paid for, nor are they blasted out in ads that fans won’t click on. They’re written, edited, and broadcast with heart, which isn’t visible in a profit/loss sheet but is the most valuable thing in the entire industry.

3) Accusations of a certain set of brothers fixing races while riding at high-profile tracks stop immediately.

4) Failing the previous wish being granted, those who accuse these brothers of improper activities will stop betting on races where they insist these improper activities are being conducted, rather than pumping money through the windows and enabling whatever alleged activities they’re accusing the riders of to continue.

5) Team Runhappy makes its own racetrack dedicated to him and spends all of its sponsorship money there, as opposed to permeating track feeds to where live video of the races becomes borderline unwatchable at times.

6) The Donn Handicap’s 2021 return is announced.

7) The downhill turf course at Santa Anita reopens.

8) The phrase “we’ll train up to” is uttered 50% less by connections that think a top-notch horse running third in a graded stakes race is a crisis that merits a six-month vacation.

9) The “breeze” portions of 2-year-old sales are cancelled due to horsemen refusing to participate.

10) Instead of changing tracks, whip rules, or medication schedules, we breed sounder, sturdier, stamina-oriented thoroughbreds that can withstand longer campaigns, run more frequently, and energize fans at their home tracks.

11) The word “brilliance” is banned from all racing and breeding circles, effective immediately.

12) Everyone goes to at least one new-to-them track during the upcoming calendar year.

13) Keeneland rolls out the red carpet (and turns on the heat!) if I make a spring trip I’m mulling.

14) Those familiar with Keeneland inundate me with recommendations of things to do in that neck of the woods.

15) Racing gets a new high-quality video game. “Champion Jockey,” the last title to hit major consoles, is still playable…but it came out in 2011 for prior-generation machines. Koei/Tecmo, get on this!

16) When the game gets produced, I get the master list of all the cheat codes.

17) King Elliot, my 2-year-old prodigy in “Off and Pacing,” realizes his lofty potential.

18) Elliot, my 8-year-old cat/partner in crime, stops jumping in my lap when I’m trying to handicap a race.

19) The Pink Sheet continues to be enjoyed by all who buy it outside Saratoga’s gates.

20) The handicapper on the far right of the paper’s pick box retains his title for what would be a fifth Pink Sheet championship in the last seven years.

21) I somehow learn how to handicap steeplechase races.

22) John Shapazian of The Saratoga Special slows down enough to give the rest of us a chance to catch him for the all-media title.

23) Assuming I visit Saratoga this summer, I get to patronize Walt and Whitman Brewing, which pays homage to The Saratogian (the building’s prior tenant) by having editions of the paper and The Pink Sheet on its walls.

24) Jokes about my picks literally being in the toilet (since Pink Sheets are on the bathroom walls, too) are kept to a minimum.

25) This year’s Triple Crown races go off without a hitch, with horses running clean races and ideally not dumping riders out of the gate.

26) Racing’s big events are marketed smartly, with materials aimed at people who will actually wager on the races.

27) Artifacts at major racetracks are not obstructed, at all, for any reason.

28) Those with ideas to improve the sport get an environment in which to debate freely, constructively, and with a shared interest in improving the game.

29) Trolls with no ideas who don’t have the guts to put their faces and names on what they post lose every photo finish for the rest of time.

30) The Vosburgh gets its Grade 1 status restored.

31) Every graded stakes race restricted to 3-year-olds after October 1st gets knocked down at least one level. If you don’t beat older horses after that date, you don’t get to claim a Grade 1.

32) The Santa Anita Handicap gets moved to the last weekend in April or Memorial Day, in order to preserve its importance.

33) Either way, the Santa Anita Handicap now starts a three-race series featuring the Gold Cup at Santa Anita (on Memorial Day or the Fourth of July) and the Pacific Classic (which remains in August).

34) When the term “handicap” is used to describe a race, it’s accurate. The days of differences between top and bottom weights being five pounds are done.

35) Tracks with access to casinos and sports books utilize these platforms to get gamblers to put money through the racing windows.

36) A solution to late odds changes gets worked out and implemented immediately.

37) If this means widespread exchange wagering with fixed odds, find a way to roll it out in such a fashion that tracks don’t go broke.

38) Short-term sacrifices for long-term gain are viewed as necessary rather than burdensome.

39) The Breeders’ Cup Derby is always viewed as the worst idea in the history of horse racing.

40) Plans are announced that will bring the Breeders’ Cup back to New York. I understand there are political barriers in place, but if I’m wishing, I’m wishing big.

41) The Breeders’ Cup Dirt Mile, Filly and Mare Sprint, and Juvenile Turf Sprint are dissolved, and their purses are re-allocated to races that would benefit from runners in those races going elsewhere.

42) Bettors get protected.

43) In that vein, all horses that break through starting gates prior to a race become immediate scratches.

44) Additionally, New York’s “purse money only” rule (which I’ve written about several times) gets kicked to the curb. If this means no more entries until a better rule is written, so be it.

45) If a top official in racing can’t explain to a novice within 20 seconds why things are what they are in certain parts of the sport, the rule or standard in question gets rewritten at one’s earliest possible convenience.

46) On-track concession prices are brought down to Earth, especially for track-goers who bet. We’ll start with people who bet $50 on a card getting a 25% discount across the board and go up from there.

47) Every Twitter fight within the horse racing community gets a poll popping up after its conclusion asking who won. Winners advance to a battle royal held at the Beemie Awards after-party.

48) More people participate in Operation Gift Horse. 2019 was my first year, and it was an absolute pleasure to take part.

49) Less people participate in behavior that reflects poorly on the sport to novice fans. Also, the less we’re in bed with organizations that promote misogyny, the better.

50) We’ll end with my personal favorite: All serious horseplayers get one “STOP THE RACE!” button to use at a single solitary point in their lifetimes. Use it however you want, but once you do, it’s gone for good.

A 50-Point Plan for Horse Racing’s Future

There are certain things one should not do. In addition to tugging on Superman’s cape, spitting into the wind, and pulling the mask off the Lone Ranger, you should never, ever challenge me publicly to put way too much thought into something.

As a preface: Bloodstock agent Bradley Weisbord publicly asserted his desire for racing to associate itself more with Barstool Sports, a controversial entity that has, in my opinion, been rightfully skewered by much of the racing community for its attitudes and actions towards women. I voiced my opinion in response to a comment by photographer Susie Raisher, and this is how Bradley reacted.

I’ve never met Bradley Weisbord in person. I’m not going to make any assertions about his motives or any of his thoughts or actions. This column is strictly business.

You see, I’ve been challenged, and I am going to rise to meet it. Here’s how, as Racing Czar, I would improve horse racing from the top down, in 50 easy steps.

1) Promote from within to account for many resignations across racing that would undoubtedly take place following the announcement of my appointment.

2) Any remaining spots would be filled by passionate young men and women who want to make a difference in the game. Their jobs will be to come up with innovative ideas and how to implement them for the sport’s long-term survival.

3) No idea is a bad idea, except for the Breeders’ Cup Derby, which is the worst idea in the history of the sport.

4) If we’re still short on people, we’re cloning Tom Durkin like Dolly the Sheep as many times as needed.

5) The horse comes first. We’re breeding to race, not racing to breed, and as such, breeders need to get with the program.

6) All, ahem, “breeze” portions of 2-year-old sales are eliminated. You want to gallop horses on the track? That’s fine. The days of an ability to “breeze” an eighth of a mile as a 2-year-old being more important, in some circles, than that horse going nine or 10 furlongs as a 4-year-old or 5-year-old are over.

7) Racing needs its stars to run for as long as possible. To promote this, any male horse retired to breed as a 4-year-old may only be bred to 50 mares. If stallion owners want to jack up stud fees to compensate for the restriction, that’s fine. We’ll let the market determine if it works.

8) We’re commissioning a long-term study on race-day medications by an impartial, unbiased group of equine scientists and medical professionals.

9) Whatever that study says, we’re going with, and all jurisdictions will follow the same rules.

10) If you’re a horseman and your horse needs Lasix or another medication to treat a legitimate issue, your horse goes on a list maintained by the neutral party and gets re-evaluated every three months.

11) If your horse needs Lasix or another medication because you think it’s a performance-enhancer, you can go train somewhere else.

12) Our medication policies have punishments with teeth.

13) Violations get grouped into “minor” and “major” infractions. Minor infractions (think overages by a few picograms or nanograms) are met by increasing fines, with the fifth violation and those beyond that being met with 30-day suspensions.

14) Major infractions are met by suspensions of 60 days, six months, and one year, followed by a lifetime ban for the fourth.

15) A national board of vets and horsemen get to decide which substances fit into which categories, and the standards apply to all tracks as part of the NTRA’s safety accreditation program.

16) The safety accreditation program also contains regulations pertaining to fouls and disqualifications, which will be drafted on the advice of jockeys, trainers, and stewards.

17) These regulations will apply across the board. The inquiry, “what is a foul that merits disqualification?,” is no longer a trick question. Every rider and steward at every track in the country now plays by and officiates the same rules, and bettors know for sure when a DQ could likely occur.

18) The same rules apply to all races regardless of status. We’re not making exceptions in Grade 1 events just because more eyes are on us.

19) If a track chooses not to comply with rules pertaining to overages and disqualifications, not only will it not earn safety accreditation, but it sacrifices graded status for all of its stakes races as well.

20) Optics matter.

21) Any trainer found to have directly sent a thoroughbred from a track to the slaughter pipeline gets booted from the game. No exceptions.

22) No organization whose stated goal is to end horse racing gets to help make decisions within the sport.

23) If organizations outlined in step 22 have strategies to hit racing hard, we hit back harder. The days of the sport being a punching bag for well-coordinated attack campaigns are done.

24) It is made clear horses on racetracks get far better care than cats and dogs at shelters run by one group that euthanizes thousands of them on a yearly basis.

25) It is also made clear that the head of a prominent organization striving for the extinction of horses had no problem profiting off of animals when he was putting the end products of them on pizzas sold at his restaurants.

26) We’re reopening the hill at Santa Anita.

27) We’re reopening Hialeah Park, by any means necessary.

28) We’re issuing moratoriums on the extension of meets at Saratoga and Del Mar. Boutique meets are boutique meets for a reason.

29) Tracks will work together to coordinate post times whenever it is feasible to do so. Instead of fighting each other for the same gambling dollars, we’re creating more opportunities for churn.

30) “Post time” means “post time.” Barring emergency situations (waiting for ambulances, technical/starting gate malfunctions, etc.), every effort must be made to run races at their listed times.

31) Penalties for post time violations will be mandatory donations to thoroughbred aftercare foundations. If you want to set up a day where you intentionally drag to set up donations for PR purposes, that’s just fine.

32) Fans that go to the track will receive vouchers at the gate. Grandstand admission is good for a $5 voucher. Clubhouse admission is good for a $10 voucher.

33) These vouchers are good for wagering only and cannot be cashed out. If a few first-time track-goers make money with their first bets, we’re convincing them to bet their winnings back, stay involved in the sport, and, most importantly to the future of the game, come back with their friends.

34) We’re optimizing the betting experience to make it easier for new players to understand what’s going on. If racing is marketed as the original fantasy sport, with a new draft taking place every 30 minutes, how much easier is that to understand than a set of past performances that, to a racing neophyte, may as well be Egyptian hieroglyphics?

35) We’re setting national standards for takeout and breakage. No track will institute rates of greater than 18% on win-place-show bets or 20% on exotics.

36) Tracks will be encouraged to find new wagers to try. Not all of them will work (hi, Horse Racing Roulette!), but some will (the low-takeout Stronach 5 is good, clean fun, for instance). We’re going to take chances, make mistakes, and get messy.

37) Transparency is key. The more people trust our product, the more they’ll trust betting on it.

38) Partnerships in owning horses are fun. Not knowing how much of each horse is owned by which stakeholder is grating. Those numbers get published.

39) Reasons for trainer changes get published (Runhappy’s page would have been positively fascinating).

40) Replays of each race run around the country are made available at the end of each racing day to all fans, without restrictions.

41) Equibase data is made available to any individuals who want to use it, for a small annual fee. This prevents a repeat of the Handycapper saga and allows passionate fans another way to explore the sport.

42) Corporations are not individuals.

43) We will market the sport with both respect for the customer and enthusiasm that, as of now, is usually only reserved for big days.

44) Those big days will market horses and the humans around them above all else. Music and fashion can play secondary roles, but all marketing materials will have at least one horse in them.

45) Horse emojis do not count as horses within those marketing materials.

46) If and when a horse breaks down, we will be honest, forthright, and not hold back details.

47) If there are problems with breakdowns, we will find solutions, not scapegoats.

48) We will effectively police ourselves so that government officials with lobbyists in their ears have as little reason as possible to attack the business.

49) We will foster environments where healthy debate, constructive criticism, and hearty competition are welcome and encouraged. Racing is, above all else, a pari-mutuel game where bettors compete with one another for money in the pools.

50) We will not foster environments where those who degrade certain parts of the population can spread their beliefs to others, nor ones where those opinions are valued more than those of people who have spent years in the business.

– – – – –

If anyone wants to discuss any of this with me, you’re welcome to do so. My Twitter DM’s are open, and the “contact” feature of my site sends messages straight to my email. I read everything that comes through, and I respond to an awful lot of it.

THE DARK DAY FILES: A Struggle with Perceived Irrelevance

Sean Clancy’s a better writer than I am. I take no shame in saying that, nor do I feel a sense of defeat, because he’s better than just about everyone. My name is on the extensive list of former interns at The Saratoga Special that went on to long careers in the racing business, and as I half-joked on Twitter a few weeks ago, I sincerely hope I’m not the Eric Mangini to the Clancys’ Bill Belichick.

Sean’s annual “I’ll miss/won’t miss” column is a must-read, and it was published Sunday. There’s a line in there that hit me like a ton of bricks, though, as good writing is prone to do.

“I’ll miss the enthusiastic interns, their futures ahead of them,” he wrote. “I won’t miss the jaded veterans, their irrelevance grinding away at them.”

I’m not taking this as a shot against me. I haven’t been to Saratoga yet this year, so I’m not in a position where I could be someone Sean would mention in that regard. However, that one line made me think more than just about anything else I’ve read in a long time, and this column spawns from that train of thought.

– – – – –

Those who followed me last year may remember a column I filed upon the completion of the 2018 Saratoga meet. It came hours after I fell one win short of Liam Durbin, largely due to three lost photo finishes in the last two days, and was written following a soul-searching meal eaten at a local dive bar.

Two days later, after working 36 hours over the course of Labor Day weekend (largely thanks to a situation involving gunfire at Del Mar), I was informed that my full-time position at The Daily Racing Form was being transitioned to part-time. This came a few weeks after a satisfactory evaluation, and was a continuation of layoffs at the publication that came earlier in the summer. When I left that part-time position for a full-time role at a non-racing company in November (the less said about my four months at that job, the better), that position was not filled.

Over the past year, racing has done a tremendous job of scaring off passionate people. The Stronach Group laid off a bunch of them late last year, and DRF had a widely-publicized round of cuts earlier this summer that claimed a number of visible writers and content contributors (several of whom I consider friends).

It’s brought about a real identity crisis for me, one that I wrote about back in November. If we’re mostly in agreement that racing needs knowledgeable handicappers who can make the sport more fun for novices, which in turn drives handle and adds repeat customers, why are such people being forced out?

I grew up reading the New York City papers and spending the lion’s share of drives to Saratoga pulling out the racing sections of The New York Daily News and The New York Post. This was a time when major newspapers had racing writers and full-time handicappers, as well as space for content contributors to expound on what was going on. Like many other racing enthusiasts, I worshipped Russ Harris, laughed at the antics of the participants in the annual “Battle of Saratoga,” and strained my eyes to read the small, blocky text that was found in the Post’s racing section at the time.

I’d wind up sharing press boxes with those folks, and many of them became my friends. Now, it’s an effort to see where they’re at. I sat behind Paul Moran, John Pricci, and Jerry Bossert (among others) for two summers at Saratoga. Paul is dead, John spends most of the year in Florida, and Jerry was laid off by the Daily News not long after I left for California. The Post laid off its racing team as well, indirectly sparking one of the weirdest sagas of my life involving a $70 Kentucky Derby future bet (P.S.: John paid up).

HRTV, the network I moved 3,000 miles west to work for, is long gone, having been purchased by TVG in early-2015. I was hired over as part of the acquisition. The first two years of my tenure there were some of the most enjoyable times I’ve had at any job (those close to me know why). The last two months were some of the least enjoyable times I’d had up to that point (again, those close to me know why), and that experience prompted a move over to DRF.

It’s 2019 now, a year after I was informed of my change in employment status at The Daily Racing Form, and Saratoga is the one time where I get to test my skills against some of the best handicappers in the game on a daily basis. For 10 months out of the year, I’m a semi-professional handicapper who uses racing as a side hustle. For the other two, I go 15 rounds with some of the smartest, sharpest horseplayers I’ve ever known, and every once in a while, magic happens (as it did in 2017, when I topped all public handicappers with 128 top-pick winners). That’s why it means so much to me to be a part of The Pink Sheet’s pick box, as I have been for seven seasons, and it’s also why I take what I do incredibly seriously.

I know that I’m fortunate to have had my experiences, and it’s not like I’m detached from the racing industry. I still freelance for DRF with two Formulator videos per week, and I’ve been able to pick up writing assignments for Horse Racing Nation, Trainer Magazine, Granite Media, and a few other outlets. I maintain my ballots for both Eclipse Awards and racing’s Hall of Fame, and I consider both of those to be tremendous honors.

Having said that, Sean’s words hit me hard. I’m 30 years old, passionate about horse racing, and eager to teach people who want to know more about it. However, I don’t care about the social side of racing. As a goofy guy with no patience for those who are blind to the necessity of gambling money in this sport, I’m never going to be the focus of one of those “I Am Horse Racing” videos. I don’t bet enough to be considered a big player, and my emergence as a handicapper/content producer wasn’t necessarily anyone’s idea. I know that doesn’t sit well with at least one person in power at a major company, and I’m sure there are some in the sport who would like nothing more than for me to sit down, shut up, and do something else.

Does that make me irrelevant? Does that make those similar to me irrelevant? Are people like me simply shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic as foal crops decline, field sizes shrink, and handfuls of trainers get most of the top-tier horses? All of these are really tough questions, and they’re ones I’m now pondering a lot as I prepare to venture east later this week.

– – – – –

This Wednesday, I’ll be spending lots of time in the air en route to upstate New York. Over the course of a week or so, I’ll be seeing my family (including my two adorable nieces), mooching lots of free food, and, of course, making several trips to Saratoga to watch horses turn left.

I’ll be at the track Thursday, Saturday, and Sunday, and if you see me walking around, don’t be afraid to say hello. I greatly appreciate anyone who takes the time to read my stuff (either in print or online), and I see that as validation for the effort I put into trying to solve 10 or so handicapping puzzles each day. Each puzzle, by the way, has become incredibly important. I’m locked in a three-way battle for top honors in The Pink Sheet, and have two wins to make up on Liam Durbin with six cards left in the meet.

I don’t know if I’m irrelevant. Maybe I always have been. Maybe we all are (we certainly will be if protestors have their way). Here’s what I know: I enjoy the hell out of this game. I love reading the past performances and trying to find things others don’t see. I’m going to keep doing this for as long as racing’s media outlets will have me, and for as long as people keep reading my stuff. Want to reach out? Tweet me at @AndrewChampagne, or email me using my site’s “contact” section. I try to respond to everything I get (just don’t use the term Runhappy on Twitter; I’ve muted it, so I won’t see your tweet if you do that).

The people who don’t like me aren’t going to change their minds. I’ve been at peace with that for a pretty long time (it’s sort of a family curse). Maybe I’m irrelevant in the grand scheme of things, but it’s not for a lack of trying to grow the game. I’m going to be around for as long as people will have me, and I’m always going to believe I’m one of the better ones at what I do.

As far as writing, though…yeah, Sean’s better than me.