SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, And Bankroll (6/7/24)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $160

I host a podcast with my good friend Josh Rodriguez over on the “On the Wrong Lead” network. It’s called “Drank’n Champagne,” and this week, we took a look at Friday’s late Pick Four sequence.

I gave out a pretty cheap play there, and if you’re looking for extensive analysis of that sequence, you can get it by watching on YouTube or listening wherever you get your podcasts.

THURSDAY’S RESULTS: Romantic Charmer was rank throughout in the eighth. I dropped $40.

FRIDAY’S PLAY: My late Pick Four starts a bit later than I’d like for the purposes of this section, and I want to make sure my editors don’t miss print deadlines before Saturday’s card. As such, I’ll focus on the eighth race and my best bet of the day. That’s #6 EL CAPI, who hits me as a potential monster. I’ll have a $30 win bet on that one, and I’ll also use him to finish off a cold $20 double starting in the seventh with #4 MUNNYS GOLD.

TOTAL WAGERED: $50.

Winners and Whiners is your home for the best sports betting promos on the market. Check out expert handicapping picks for all major sports, including baseball, basketball, hockey, and football!

SELECTIONS/ANALYSIS

Best Bet: El Capi, Race 8
Longshot: Addicted to You, Race 3

R1

Rolling Along
Trulli Warrior
Pentathlon

#8 ROLLING ALONG (6-1): Has experience, unlike many other top contenders here, and exits a swiftly-run race at this distance over Woodbine’s synthetic surface. This barn excels with second-time starters, and this one adds both Lasix and blinkers in the Friday lid-lifter; #1 TRULLI WARRIOR (7/2): Is one of two first-time starters trained by Todd Pletcher, and this one’s bred to be a runner. This son of Curlin has a very strong bottom-side pedigree, too, and several of his recent works indicate he’s got plenty of talent; #3 PENTATHLON (12-1): Hasn’t run since October but caught two very tough fields before going to the sidelines. He improved considerably at second asking, is working consistently for Shug McGaughey, and could be a contender at a price if he’s ready to run.

R2

Arthur’s Ride
Leading Contender
Tapit Shoes

#1 ARTHUR’S RIDE (3-1): Comes in off of an absolute clunker that was too bad to be true. Maybe he bounced off of a fantastic two-back effort, maybe he just hated the slop, but either way, I think he comes back to form stretching out to a distance he’s bred to relish; #5 LEADING CONTENDER (5/2): Gets a big rider switch to Flavien Prat and generally fires the same shot every time out. That’s been enough to get him seven top-two finishes in nine career starts, but only two of those races are wins, and he’s burned a lot of money over the course of his career; #9 TAPIT SHOES (8-1): Came off the bench to top first-level allowance foes at Churchill in his first start since August. He’s listed as a first-time gelding in this spot, and this son of Tapit is another that’s bred to enjoy this 10-furlong trip.

R3

Storming Chrome (MTO)
Liar’s Poker
Addicted to You

#14 LIAR’S POKER (7/2): Needs two scratches to draw in but is a major player if he does. His lone misfire to date came in a stakes race against much tougher horses, and I think he’ll be fit to fire a big shot in his second start off a long break; #5 ADDICTED TO YOU (8-1): Is one of several exiting the same race on May 4th, and I think he ran very well to be third that day. There was no early speed in there, yet he came flying late to be beaten less than a length in his first start since November. There seems to be more speed signed on here, which should help him; #8 LORD FLINTSHIRE (6-1): Has a troubling aversion to winning and is just 1-for-23 in his career. However, he’s run second eight times, goes second off the bench for a strong barn, and ran well here twice a season ago against similar stock.

R4

Notah
Debate
Lucency

#4 NOTAH (9/2): Hasn’t run a bad race in any of his last five tries, and he’s never missed the board in four starts at this seven-furlong distance. The rider switch to Irad Ortiz, Jr., is a big one, and I think he could sit an ideal stalking trip; #8 DEBATE (3-1): Cuts back to one turn after a failed two-turn experiment last month. His two and three-back efforts going a mile at Aqueduct were fine, and a return to form makes him a major player; #9 LUCENCY (7/2): Just missed in a similar spot downstate and has every right to contend in this one. This is his second start since being claimed by a low-percentage outfit, though, so while his best race could win this, it’s fair to wonder if a regression is in the cards.

R5

Cees Get Degrees (MTO)
Boat’s a Rockin
Mischievous Angel

#5 BOAT’S A ROCKIN (8-1): Exits a much tougher spot on the Preakness undercard where he set the pace over a boggy turf course in his first start since November. He gets Lasix back for this one, and while I don’t think we’ll quite get the 8-1 morning line price, the last-out clunker may inflate his odds just a bit; #10 MISCHIEVOUS ANGEL (4-1): Came back running off the bench to top first-level allowance foes in his first run since August. Prat sees fit to ride back, and his lone loss to date came in a Grade 2 here last year, one won by the classy Carl Spackler; #3 CLEAR THE AIR (7/2): Ran second behind the ageless Bound for Nowhere last time out, and his two-back score in a turf sprint at Keeneland was sharp. This turned out to be a very tough spot for the level, but a repeat of that April 21 effort would put him right there.

R6

Top Conor (MTO)
Spirit Prince
Time Song

#6 SPIRIT PRINCE (7/2): Has a significant back class edge over most of these and will be a formidable foe if he’s ready off the bench. All but one of his five starts last year came against stakes foes, and he won one of those races (the Central Park at Aqueduct); #4 TIME SONG (12-1): Faltered as an 8/5 favorite in a stakes race at Gulfstream but gets some class relief in this spot. He also gets Lasix back, and his lone race with Lasix is by far his best effort; #9 ARMY OFFICER (9/2): Has taken steps forward in each career start and exits a strong second at Churchill last month. He’s got some tactical speed and attracts Frankie Dettori, who doesn’t ride for this barn that much.

R7

Munnys Gold
Sam’s Treasure
Roswell

#4 MUNNYS GOLD (6/5): Is probably the most likely winner on the Friday card. We haven’t seen her since a third-place finish in the Grade 1 Test, and she returns in a first-level allowance where she’ll be allowed to run with Lasix; #8 SAM’S TREASURE (8-1): Ran well in her 2024 debut, when she was second behind a next-out winner in her first start since September. Unlike many others in here, she can stalk the pace and pass others late, which could prove to be very valuable; #3 ROSWELL (5-1): Hasn’t run a poor race to date and cuts back in distance after 7 1/2 furlongs proved to be just a bit too far. Her two prior efforts at Gulfstream Park were solid, and a repeat of those performances would likely get her a piece of this one.

R8

El Capi
Brown entry
One Giant Leap

#6 EL CAPI (4-1): Looked like a monster in his unveiling, when he crushed an overmatched field at Aqueduct and earned a 99 Beyer Speed Figure. We haven’t seen him since then, but he’s working steadily for a barn that can be pretty patient, and if he’s right, look out; BROWN ENTRY (5/2): I prefer #1 GENERAL PARTNER, who was second in last year’s Grade 1 Champagne before faltering in the Grade 1 Breeders’ Cup Juvenile. He’s been working well ahead of his seasonal debut, and it wouldn’t be a surprise if this was a prep for a much bigger spot later this summer; #10 ONE GIANT LEAP (15-1): Likely lost his 2024 debut at the starting gate, as he was a non-factor as a 6/5 favorite after a slow break. His late-2023 form, however, was pretty strong, and I’m expecting, well, one giant leap forward for very capable connections at a juicy price.

R9

Roses for Debra
Gal in a Rush
Love Reigns

#6 ROSES FOR DEBRA (6/5): Came back running with a win in the Grade 3 Giant’s Causeway and is a very logical favorite in the Grade 2 Intercontinental. She went 2-for-2 here last year, including a win in the Grade 3 Caress, and seems the most likely winner and new Intercontinental Champion; #8 GAL IN A RUSH (10-1): Returned with a strong second in the License Fee downstate and got pretty good last year before going to the sidelines. Flavien Prat sees fit to ride back for Christophe Clement, who may very well run 1-2 in here; #10 LOVE REIGNS (3-1): Chased my top pick last time and figures to get plenty of pace to run at in her second start off the bench. She’s shown plenty of talent in the past, and this will be her first start without a layoff line in the form since mid-2022.

R10

Gina Romantica
Chili Flag
Coppice

#3 GINA ROMANTICA (3-1): Is one of five Chad Brown trainees in the Grade 1 Just A Game, and she cuts back to her preferred one-mile trip second off the bench. Unlike last time, in the Grade 1 Jenny Wiley, she should have some pace to chase, which is a must given her late-running style; #6 CHILI FLAG (4-1): Notched her third win in the last four starts in the Grade 2 Distaff Turf Mile. Toss her dud three back at Gulfstream, and you have a classy mare that hasn’t done much wrong at all over the last year and a half; #4 COPPICE (3-1): Was a close-up second behind my second choice last time out at Churchill, and she might have needed that race off a long break. She ran with the likes of Inspiral and Nashwa overseas last year, and improvement is logical second off the bench.

R11

Didia
War Like Goddess
American Sonja

#3 DIDIA (9/2): Stretches back out to her preferred trip and gets a tepid nod in a wide-open renewal of the Grade 1 New York. She’s proven at this distance and should be able to sit an ideal stalking trip, which would give her first run turning for home; #10 WAR LIKE GODDESS (4-1): Has been a stalwart of the turf the last several years and makes her first start since last year’s Grade 1 Breeders’ Cup Turf. She’s never been out of the exacta in five local starts, and she’s a major player if she’s ready to run; #5 AMERICAN SONJA (10-1): Ships in from Europe and attracts Frankie Dettori, which is always enough to merit consideration. She most recently captured a Group 3 in France, but she’s run fairly well stateside, too, having finished second in last year’s Grade 3 Saratoga Oaks.

R12

Thorpedo Anna
Just F Y I
Power Squeeze

#9 THORPEDO ANNA (8/5): Comes in off of an authoritative score in the Grade 1 Kentucky Oaks and looms large despite a tricky outside draw. She’s trained forwardly since that performance, and if she’s right, she’ll once again be a handful in the Grade 1 Acorn; #4 JUST F Y I (5/2): Gave my top pick a scare at the top of the stretch in the Oaks before finishing a best-of-the-rest second. This is her third start off the layoff, and the local drills are certainly eye-catching; #2 POWER SQUEEZE (12-1): Was never comfortable in the Oaks, where she broke next-to-last and had to navigate a sloppy track she may not have cared for. Prior to that clunker, she reeled off four straight wins, and the jockey switch to Javier Castellano could help her get back on track.

SARATOGA RACE COURSE: Analysis, Selections, And Bankroll (6/6/24)

BANKROLL

BANKROLL: $200

First and foremost, it’s fantastic to be back. I’m grateful to the management of The Saratogian and Raketech for allowing me to do this again, and I’m excited to get back into the swing of things during an exciting, history-making week in upstate New York.

If you’re new to this, a quick crash course: In addition to selections and analysis for every race, I’ve got a section where I can expound on money management and, hopefully, parlay my picks and thoughts into smart bets that make money. If the top-three picks are Handicapping 101, this is Handicapping 201. There’s no way to give picks and analysis that pleases everyone (thanks, horse racing Twitter!), but this way reaches wide groups of people with varying levels of experience, and it’s one that we’ve seen works over time.

For the summer meet, I’ll have a $1,000 bankroll to use over the 40-day schedule. I’m treating this as a separate endeavor and giving myself $200 over the Belmont Stakes Racing Festival. Let’s see what we can do.

THURSDAY’S PLAYS: We’ll head to the eighth race, where I think #1 ROMANTIC CHARMER has a big chance to improve in his first turf start against a field that includes multiple horses coming off of long layoffs. I’ll key that one in $5 exactas above and below #6 FILM ACADEMY, #7 ALL GOOD HERE, and #9 MISSION HILL, and I’ll also have a $10 win bet on him. As a reminder, bets in turf races assume those events stay on they grass, and surface changes cancel all tickets.

TOTAL WAGERED: $40.

Winners and Whiners is your home for the best sports betting promos on the market. Check out expert handicapping picks for all major sports, including baseball, basketball, hockey, and football!

SELECTIONS/ANALYSIS

Best Bet: Three Echoes, Race 2
Longshot: Romantic Charmer, Race 8

R1

Drunk On Sake
Bookworm
Caesar’s Ghost

#5 DRUNK ON SAKE (8-1): Didn’t do much running in his career debut, but he takes a significant drop at second asking, adds both Lasix and blinkers, and could improve going to the turf. His pedigree says he’ll like the lawn, and that may be enough against a suspect group; #6 BOOKWORM (7/5): Will be a significant favorite, but I have my doubts. This is a strong barn, but the outfit is 0-for-12 with first-out maiden claimers going back to mid-July of 2022, and seeing a $150,000 purchase debut for a $40,000 tag is a red flag; #12 CAESAR’S GHOST (9/2): Needs some luck to draw in off the AE list, but he ran reasonably well in three turf races against maiden special weight foes. The layoff is a concern, but anything close to his last-out performance at Kentucky Downs would give him a big shot.

R2

Three Echoes
Touchy
Classic of Course

#5 THREE ECHOES (5/2): Got a lot of experience in his debut, when he overcame considerable trouble to win at first asking. That’s not something 2-year-olds often do, and I think he’s very well-meant coming into the Tremont; #7 TOUCHY (2-1): Debuts for Wesley Ward, who’s one of the best first-out trainers in the game. His works are strong, and there’s every reason to think he’s well-meant, but given his pedigree, I wonder if he wants a bit longer than this 5 1/2-furlong trip; #8 CLASSIC OF COURSE (7/2): Led every step of the way in his debut at Gulfstream and attracts Irad Ortiz, Jr. It’s unlikely another perfect trip will materialize here, but he certainly figures to be prominent from the start.

R3

Caldo Candy
Silver Satin
Land d’Oro

#2 CALDO CANDY (3-1): Has yet to run a truly bad race to this point and was a solid second at this level last time out downstate. That day’s winner came right back to win again, and the recent bullet drill over this surface is encouraging; #5 SILVER SATIN (5/2): Faces winners for the first time after graduating in a swiftly-run maiden race in April. He’s yet to run out of the exacta in three starts, and the step up in class may not be too much of a problem; #7 LAND D’ORO (4-1): Cuts back to seven furlongs after finishing second going a mile back in April. His lone win to date came at this distance, and the jockey switch to soon-to-be Hall of Fame rider Joel Rosario is a big one.

R4

Almostgone Rocket
Manama Gold
Becky’s Joker

#5 ALMOSTGONE ROCKET (6/5): Has been extremely impressive in two starts to date, including a first-level allowance score on Kentucky Oaks Day. Unlike many others in the Jersey Girl, she’s shown she doesn’t need the lead to run well, and she looms very, very large; #4 MANAMA GOLD (6-1): Went 3-for-3 in Dubai earlier this year, including a win in the Group 3 UAE Oaks. She hasn’t run since february, but her workouts are solid enough and she’s another that could be sitting just off of a very hot pace; #3 BECKY’S JOKER (8-1): Captured the Grade 3 Schuylerville last time out in her career unveiling, but went to the sidelines after a dud a few weeks later. She’s been working well for patient connections and could be another beneficiary of the likely race shape.

R5

In the End
Strictly Taboo
Heart of the Night

#6 IN THE END (9/2): Gets a tepid top pick in a turf sprint where I’m truly not in love with any runner. She, however, goes second off the bench and faces state-bred company for the first time, so there’s reason to believe she’ll move forward; #1 STRICTLY TABOO (3-1): Ran well at this level several times last year and gets reunited with Joel Rosario in her first try since October. Christophe Clement can get horses ready to run off the bench, and she’ll be a major player if she can overcome the inside draw; #9 HEART OF THE NIGHT (5-1): Comes east after starting her career in California and is another facing NY-breds for the first time. Her last two races weren’t anything to write home about, but her 2022 and early-2023 form is strong enough to merit consideration.

R6

Pletcher entry
She’s Wicked Smart
Silvology

PLETCHER ENTRY (6/5): Both #1 CHANTEUSE and #1A AUDACIOUS could win. It would appear they’ve worked in company the last few weeks, and they both draw top-class riders for their respective unveilings; #5 SHE’S WICKED SMART (4-1): Ran well when third in her debut last summer behind Just F Y I, who ultimately wound up becoming the top 2-year-old filly in the country. She’s been off more than nine months, but she’s worked steadily and has every right to be a good one; #2 SILVOLOGY (12-1): Has a very classy pedigree and fired a bullet drill downstate last week for a trainer that doesn’t often ask much of unraced horses. Most of the pedigree says she’d be a top-class turf horse, but she’s flashed enough potential to indicate she could factor in this dirt event at a price.

R7

Ways and Means
Miz Sense
Broderie

#7 WAYS AND MEANS (2/5): Exits the Grade 1 Kentucky Oaks, where she was fourth behind Thorpedo Anna and may have been going a bit longer than she wants to run. The cutback to a mile should suit her perfectly, she gets Lasix for the first time, and the class relief is a big, big plus; #4 MIZ SENSE (8-1): Won first time out at this route, which is a tricky thing to do, and hasn’t been seen in the afternoon since she lost Manny Franco at the start of the Grade 1 Spinaway. She comes back for Pletcher here, while adding Lasix and Irad Ortiz, Jr.; #6 BRODERIE (10-1): Won a pair of restricted races in Florida before shipping to Aqueduct and finishing second at this distance. That day’s winner, Midtown Lights, is a solid runner, and this one may sit an ideal stalking trip.

R8

Iron Man Ira (MTO)
Romantic Charmer
Film Academy

#1 ROMANTIC CHARMER (8-1): Tries turf for the first time, and his pedigree says he’ll love it. He’s by Mendelssohn, out of a Langfuhr mare, and he may not have to move forward much off of his dirt races to win this (his last-out Beyer Speed Figure of 72 is the highest number in the main body of the field); #6 FILM ACADEMY (7/2): Has been off four months but stretches out in his first start since January for very strong connections. He was third in his career debut last summer over this turf course, and he may be on or near the lead in a race without much early zip; #9 MISSION HILL (4-1): Is one of several comebackers, having not run since a so-so fourth at this route in late-August. He’s been gelded since that effort, and a logical move forward would put him right there if he’s ready to run.

R9

Long Neck Paula
French Horn
Aoraki

#9 LONG NECK PAULA (2-1): Cruised to an easy win in her debut over 10 rivals at Keeneland and draws a cushy outside post in the Astoria. Her recent local drill was solid enough, and when Wesley Ward gets young horses on the right track, they tend to stay there; #3 FRENCH HORN (7/2): Wired the field in her debut over Woodbine’s synthetic track and sports a recent bullet drill that suggests dirt won’t be a problem here. Flavien Prat hops aboard this daughter of the mare Emma’s Encore, who gave H. Allen Jerkens his last Grade 1 win in the 2012 Prioress here at Saratoga; #2 AORAKI (5-1): Debuted with a win in a restricted race at Churchill Downs, but despite my concerns about what she beat, I have to admit she won the right way. The Steve Asmussen trainee showed some grit and passed others late, which isn’t the traditional winning trip for a first-time starter.

R10

Dai Vernon (MTO)
Siskany
The Grey Wizard

#12 SISKANY (1-1): Ships in for the Godolphin/Charles Appleby partnership, which has won some of America’s biggest turf races over the last few years. Also in tow is regular rider William Buick, who’s piloted this gelding to many of his 10 career wins (including last year’s renewal of this race, the Grade 2 Belmont Gold Cup); #11 THE GREY WIZARD (8-1): Goes third off the bench for Graham Motion and stepped forward when third in the Grade 3 Louisville last time out. He was second in this race a year ago and reunites with Hall of Fame jockey John Velazquez; #3 REALLY GOOD (15-1): Is one of several Mike Maker trainees in this field, and he comes in off of a win downstate. He won the Kent Stakes going long last year, and his plodding style may mean this two-mile distance is exactly what he wants.

Justify, The Hall Of Fame, Historical Context, And A Hard Answer

Earlier this week, the National Museum of Racing and Hall of Fame announced its 17 voting finalists for its 2024 class. Those with a vote (self included) will receive ballots soon, and the top vote-getters will be enshrined in Saratoga Springs this summer.

The most polarizing name on the list is Justify. Acting as though this is straightforward either way is naive at best and biased at worst, and when I tweeted that I had absolutely no idea what I was going to do with him, I wasn’t blowing smoke.

What do writers do when things get puzzling? We write through it. With that in mind, let’s discuss the 2018 Horse of the Year and a fascinating question: Is Justify a Hall of Famer?

– – – – –

It makes sense to start with a primer on why we’re here. The case for Justify is quite simple and can be summed up in four words: Undefeated Triple Crown winner.

Justify didn’t make a single start as a 2-year-old. Instead, he broke his maiden at first asking in January, won an allowance race, beat Bolt d’Oro to the wire in the Santa Anita Derby (more on that later), and became the 13th horse to sweep America’s three marquee races for 3-year-olds (and just the second since Affirmed did it 40 years earlier).

He was retired a few months after the Belmont Stakes, and a mild Horse of the Year debate ensued when Accelerate rampaged through California’s biggest races for older horses and annexed the Breeders’ Cup Classic. Before any member of the ever-present Bob Baffert fan club goes after me, I want it noted that I strongly believed Justify was the easy Horse of the Year choice (and wrote about it on this very website).

Most voters agreed. Justify won the trophy and went off to the breeding shed. However, in the past few years, new details have come to light about a positive drug test that came after the Santa Anita Derby. The California Horse Racing Board opted not to disqualify him due to environmental contamination, but in December of 2023 (nearly six years after the race), the Los Angeles County Superior Court ordered the CHRB to set aside their ruling, DQ Justify, and install Bolt d’Oro as the race’s winner.

Without the Kentucky Derby points he earned in the Santa Anita Derby, Justify would not have made the field on the first Saturday in May. Churchill Downs has said it has no plans to alter the results of the 2018 Kentucky Derby, but it’s not illogical to wonder if he should have been in the gate.

Additionally, Justify retired after the Belmont and never faced older horses. Not running in races such as the Breeders’ Cup Classic opened the door for another runner to be considered, by some, a viable threat for Horse of the Year, and in an age where horses don’t run as much, a longer career would have certainly been more appreciated by some in the voting bloc.

– – – – –

To try to make some sense of this, I dove into the history books. On Tuesday, I asked if any Hall of Fame horse carried as much “baggage” as Justify. When in doubt, some degree of precedent helps, and I wanted to see if there were any comparable situations.

The answer: Not really. A couple of horses went through strange situations before being immortalized. Grey Lag raced at age 13 against claimers after falling into the wrong hands. Bewitch’s signature win as a 2-year-old, over Calumet Farm stablemates Citation and Free America, may not have been entirely on the level. Safely Kept may not have made it into the Hall of Fame had Dayjur not jumped a shadow late in the 1990 Breeders’ Cup Sprint. Unfortunately, that list also includes Exceller, who was enshrined in 1999 (two years after being sent to the slaughterhouse).

Those stories, though, are pretty different from the one Justify carries, so no dice there. I was, however, able to find a few answers to the “never faced older horses” question.

For the most part, horses enshrined in the Hall of Fame have some longevity to them. However, Justify would be far from the first horse to go in having never faced older rivals. I count at least five honored horses who share that distinction. That list includes another Bob Baffert trainee, Point Given, as well as Tim Tam, Count Fleet, Colin, and, sadly, the ill-fated Ruffian.

That list mainly features horses who suffered career-ending injuries. Justify did require time off, but probably could have continued racing as a 4-year-old. However, as I’ve discussed time and time again on various platforms, the breeding industry is the tail that wags the dog in racing, and there was simply much more guaranteed money to be made sending Justify to stud.

(One quick note: I’m seeing some pro-Justify people support his case by mentioning his early success as a sire. One’s breeding career should have absolutely nothing to do with a Hall of Fame case. The Hall of Fame is for what happens from the starting gate to the wire, not for the results of activities in the breeding shed. Please stop.)

I’m fairly old-school. I like when horses run for long periods of time and do so at racing’s top level. Having said that, while Justify’s short career isn’t ideal, I also can’t hold it against him too much. Add in the likelihood of fellow six-time starter Flightline being a first-ballot Hall of Famer in a few years, and it’s entirely possible longevity just doesn’t matter much anymore.

– – – – –

A unique convergence of events makes this one of the weirdest Hall of Fame questions since the institution opened its doors in the 1950’s. Bob Baffert, of course, has dealt with multiple high-profile positive drug tests. In addition to Justify, a drug test on initial 2021 Kentucky Derby winner Medina Spirit showed betamethasone, and Gamine was disqualified from a third-place finish in the 2020 Kentucky Oaks due to the presence of that same substance.

Baffert is in the Hall of Fame. In addition to Point Given, other former Baffert trainees such as Arrogate, American Pharoah, Silverbulletday, and Silver Charm all have plaques in Saratoga, too.

To call the situation awkward would be an understatement. Nothing about this feels particularly clean. A “yes” vote seems ignorant of an awful lot of facts. A “no” vote…also seems ignorant of an awful lot of facts.

In the absence of much precedent (other than “a few horses with short careers are in”), I keep coming back to the decision made by Churchill Downs. That entity, which has made zero friends in the Baffert camp over the last several years, has opted not to revisit the results of the 2018 Kentucky Derby. Given everything that’s happened since Medina Spirit crossed the wire first in 2021, CDI doing that would have been far from shocking.

Without that race on Justify’s resume, he’s almost certainly not a Hall of Famer (perhaps that incentivizes his connections to run the horse as a 4-year-old, but that’s strictly hypothetical). It being there, however, pushes Justify to a level of rarified air. The previous 12 Triple Crown winners are all enshrined in the Hall of Fame. Only one, Seattle Slew, was also undefeated when he pulled it off.

No, it’s not pretty.

No, it’s not an easy decision.

No, anyone involved in the nearly-six-years-long process to figure out what happened with the post-Santa Anita Derby positive test, and how it should affect the result of the race, should not be involved in such a decision, at all, ever again.

Yes, Justify is a Hall of Famer.

No, Kentucky Derby 150 Doesn’t Need An Asterisk

This past weekend, Nysos won the Robert Lewis Stakes at Santa Anita, and he did so very impressively. In the process, he moved his career record to a perfect 3-for-3. That effort, combined with an underwhelming showing from Fierceness in the Holy Bull at Gulfstream Park, made many think he’s the top 3-year-old in the country.

Nysos, though, won’t run in the Kentucky Derby. He’s trained by Bob Baffert, who also conditions several other top-class 3-year-olds. Baffert’s Kentucky Derby ban has been extended through this year’s renewal, and unlike the past two seasons, owners connected with those horses decided to keep their runners in the same barn.

Outcry has, predictably, been pretty harsh, and not just from the usual suspects on horse racing Twitter. Several journalists I respect a great deal have chimed in, claiming that this year’s Kentucky Derby has a stain on it from the lack of Bob Baffert trainees (several of which would be considered logical contenders).

As you can probably guess from the headline, I don’t agree with that sentiment. However, my thoughts on this are similar to the ones I had about the Alix Earle situation at the Pegasus World Cup: Many people have this very, very wrong.

I’m going to throw my readers a curveball here with this next sentence (at least in the eyes of some who will see this article): I don’t love the way Baffert was suspended an additional year. The precedent of tacking on additional time after a verdict was handed down, and as a punishment is being served, isn’t a good one.

The long-running legal battle between Churchill Downs and the Baffert/Amr Zedan camp undoubtedly played a role in this. It was ugly, and I think most of the racing world breathed a sigh of relief when Baffert and Zedan stopped pursuing the case earlier this year. I understand CDI doing what it feels is best for business, but it’s also logical to think this stacks the deck against someone who may have a legitimate case of some sort down the line.

Acting as though one person or one entity is above the game is misleading, at best. On the other hand, though…acting as though one person or one entity is above the game is misleading, at best. Much like Churchill Downs, Bob Baffert and his owners aren’t more important than the rest of the industry.

Owners of horses like Nysos had a choice. They could’ve gone the routes made popular in 2022 and 2023 and sent their Derby prospects to the barns of Tim Yakteen, Sean McCarthy, Rodolphe Brisset, Brittany Russell, or other trainers in the game. More than one trainer can condition top-tier animals. Those owners chose to go another route, and that’s their right. I won’t criticize them for doing what they feel is correct. They pay the bills, not me.

What I also won’t do, though, is act as though those people are victims. Baffert was blackballed from the Run for the Roses, not the owners. Just because those connections aren’t pointing those horses to the Kentucky Derby doesn’t mean I’m going to devalue that race, and I don’t think anyone else should, either.

Barring a flip-flop by the owners of horses like Nysos, Muth, and others, those thoroughbreds won’t be in the starting gate. That’s not ideal, and neither is acting as though everything’s fine and the efforts of those horses don’t exist (as Churchill’s doing). However, it’s not the first time horses at or near the head of the class won’t go postward on the first Saturday in May.

Horses get knocked off the Derby trail every single season. Injuries derail the chances of major players frequently. Most notably, Forte, who would’ve been favored a year ago, scratched the morning of the race. Life Is Good and Shared Belief sure would’ve made the 2021 and 2014 Derbies more interesting, too. They didn’t run, either, and both years, fans and handicappers more than made due on the first Saturday in May.

The difference, of course, is that Nysos isn’t injured. As far as we can tell, he bounced out of the Lewis well. We’ll probably see him in either the San Felipe or the Santa Anita Derby, depending on what Baffert decides to do with his other 3-year-olds, and wherever he winds up, he’ll almost certainly be a very heavy favorite (and justifiably so).

Yes, the Kentucky Derby would be better with Nysos in it. Yes, the Preakness sure looks like the Bob Baffert Invitational, where that barn will undoubtedly be loaded and ready to feast upon horses being wheeled back in two weeks and other “new shooters” that almost certainly don’t stack up well in the form. Saying otherwise is naive and acts as though a major issue doesn’t exist (which, to be fair, is in line with horse racing’s approach on other topics that it’s kicked the can down the road on and can no longer just ignore).

However, there’s a lot of blame to go around for the way this wound up. Giving the race a physical or mental asterisk solves nothing. I’ll never agree with those acting as though the Derby is somehow just another 3-year-old race because one trainer, and owners who made conscious choices to stick with that trainer, can’t participate.

(As an aside, an acquaintance of mine has said they’re taking screenshots of folks insisting they don’t care, won’t bet on the race, and making other bold statements. I look forward to the “then and now” posts made when those people inevitably cave.)

It gets old saying “everyone’s wrong.” I genuinely believe most people mean well. I don’t think anyone’s happy horse racing is in the shape it’s in right now. These conflicts, though, solve absolutely nothing and make unifying for meaningful change beyond one big day much, much harder.

Here’s hoping that stops, and does so sooner rather than later.

Alix Earle Went To The Pegasus. Horse Racing Twitter Lost Its Mind.

I write today not to bury Gulfstream Park, nor to praise it. My latest entry in the “does anyone actually read these?” files instead strikes a familiar refrain that can be applied to a staggering number of situations.

Some background, for those unfamiliar with the situation: Influencer Alix Earle attended the Pegasus World Cup Saturday. Her social media content from the event reached a staggering 6.5 million people in 24 hours. This, of course, drove horse racing Twitter bananas, with fanatics grumbling about how Earle’s presence contributed nothing to the event.

Some further background, for those unfamiliar with me (and because, the last time I did this to establish myself as an “expert witness” of sorts, a few people missed the point and lost their minds over it): I have more than 13 years of experience in digital and social media marketing. Outside of horse racing, I’ve grown brands in the non-profit and college athletics sectors. Inside of this particular industry, I’ve shepherded online outlets for some of the most well-known news and entertainment operations in the game and, of course, had Lord Miles at 59-1 in the Wood Memorial (and the reaction that gets is why I still bring it up; I know my audience!).

All of this is to say I’m as well-qualified as anybody to discuss the layers of this, and that familiar refrain I mentioned earlier is a simple one: Almost everyone is wrong in some way, shape, or form.

The first thing you do, when you want to present your product as “cool,” is find people who others think are “cool” and use them to your benefit. Given the media landscape in 2024, the best way to do this is influencer marketing, and it’s a really simple concept provided you’ve got the money to do it.

As a sport, we talk about needing to try new things to get the sport in front of new fans. Given how many people saw Alix Earle’s content, that box was checked, multiple times over. Sorry to say it, folks, but industry channels and publications aren’t reaching 6.5 million people a day. We’re all statistically insignificant by comparison.

On that level, I have no problem with the presence of Alix Earle at the Pegasus. It seems like a mutually beneficial partnership. Gulfstream gets social media exposure, and Alix Earle gets eyeballs on her content, even if those eyeballs aren’t necessarily those of hardened handicappers (whose eyeballs instead rolled hard as this content got rolled out).

To use a marketing term, though, this got people into the funnel. The next step, now that they’re there, is to convert those people into customers. So what’s Gulfstream Park doing to give these people every reason to come back to the track?

There are ways this can be done. Hit the demographics Alix Earle’s trying to hit with social media ads that have her Pegasus photos or footage in them (assuming you have the rights to something). Use what you’ve got to drive Pegasus-goers back to the racetrack more than once, and when they get there, have resources that are there to introduce people to the betting side of the game. More informed fans are better fans. Better fans wager more and are more likely to introduce the sport to their friends. This isn’t complicated.

There’s a place for influencer marketing in horse racing, but like everything else, there has to be a follow-through. Gulfstream Park has five stakes races on Saturday’s card. The headliner, the Holy Bull, features Fierceness, who’d be the Kentucky Derby favorite if the race was run right now.

Do we think the people who saw Alix Earle’s videos know that? My money’s on “no,” and that’s where it falls apart.

Alix Earle being at the Pegasus World Cup isn’t the issue. The lack of a follow-through is, and that’s where horse racing’s in trouble. If the industry isn’t marketing correctly to new fans, or to the fans it has, what’s going on here?

The data doesn’t present a pretty picture. Handle is down pretty considerably, and only being kept afloat, at some venues, by CAW groups that have certain capabilities unavailable to the average player. The increased availability of legal sports betting can’t help matters. Why go against the sharks at the racetrack when you can spend your gambling dollars at sportsbooks that know their customers and give them what they want?

At its best, horse racing is the best gambling game on the planet, and there’s no close second. It’s what got me into the game as a kid, and it’s why the only times horse racing Twitter comes together with joy is when a player makes a big score. Marketing it as the premier betting opportunity in the country isn’t going to solve all of horse racing’s ills (we’re still breeding fewer horses that don’t run as much as their predecessors), but without that, handle’s going to keep circling the drain and put the sport in an even worse position moving forward.

In that regard, I share the frustrations of my horse racing Twitter brethren at the sport’s continued inability to effectively communicate with its fanbase. That’s my “why,” and it’s a big reason why I show up with content every year at Saratoga, Pleasanton, and a few other outlets. There’s a legitimate gripe that needs to be addressed by tracks across the country, in the form of effective marketing, fan education, and getting people hooked on the game the ways many of us were.

If your problem is with Alix Earle, though, the blame is misplaced.

(Oh, and if you’ve got an issue with well-known, younger women attending sporting events and being seen a lot, you probably shouldn’t watch the Super Bowl.)